by John McCrae, May 1915
In Flanders fields the poppies blow
We are the Dead. Short days ago
by Ewart Alan Mackintosh
(Private D Sutherland killed in action in the German trenches, 16 May 1916, and the others who died.)
So you were David's father,
Oh, the letters he wrote you,
You were only David's father,
Oh, never will I forget you,
Happy and young and gallant,
Inspiration for the Poem
On the evening of 16 May, 1916 Lieutenant Ewart Alan Mackintosh and Second Lieutenant Mackay of the 5th Battalion Seaforth Highlanders led a raid on the German trenches in the sector of the front line north-west of Arras. By the end of the night there were sixteen British casualties, which included fourteen wounded and two killed. One of the two dead soldiers was Private David Sutherland.
Private David Sutherland has no known grave. His name is commemorated in Bay 8 of the Arras Memorial to the Missing at Faubourg d'Amiens military cemetery in Arras.
His letters were normally full of enthusiasm and excitement. In July 1918 he
wrote, "As you see, I am still alive and well, and as usual enjoying life to the full."
It is only in his very last letter, on 1 September 1918, that he revealed his more
reflective side.
The next day Frank Earley suffered a serious wound to his chest and died
some hours later. He was 19.
Sunday afternoon, 1 Sep, 1918.
My dear Father,
It is a strange feeling to me but a very real one,
that every letter now that I write home to you
or to the little sisters may be the last that I shall
write or you read. I do not want you to think that
I am depressed; indeed on the contrary, I am
very cheerful. But out here, in odd moments the
realisation comes to me of how close death is to us.
A week ago I was talking with a man, a catholic,
from Preston, who had been out here for nearly
four years, untouched. He was looking forward
with certainty to going on leave soon. And now
he is dead - killed in a moment during our last
advance. Well it was God's will.
I say this to you because I hope that you will
realise, as I do, the possibility of the like happening
to myself. I feel very glad myself that I can look the
fact in the face without fear or misgiving. Much as
I hope to live thro' it all for your sakes and my little
sisters! I am quite prepared to give my life as so many
have done before me. All I can do is put myself in
God's hands for him to decide, and you and the little
ones pray for me to the Sacred Heart and Our Lady.
I hope that you will not move out of the old house yet.
Write and let me know when anything happens. I see
that you went to Preston a few days ago. It seems
years and years since I tried to get drowned in the canal.
Well I have not much time left and I must end.
With my dear love. Pray for me.
Your son
Frank.
Frank Earley is buried at Bac-de-Sud Military Cemetery, Bailleulval, nr Arras.
His letters are held by the documents library at the Imperial War Museum.
Extracts appear in 1918 Year of Victory by Malcolm Brown.
28th May, 1918, Dear Father, Just a few lines in answer to your letter which I received today.Yes I have got used to the puttees, as they have shaped to my legs by now. And I am getting used to my other things now, as I have been dished out with a rifle and bayonet, and now when I go on parade I have got to wear my belt, bayonet and cartridge pouch and also take the rifle. They have been teaching us bayonet fighting today and I can tell you it makes your arms ache, when you make a point that is, when you lunge out at imaginary enemy, with the rifle at arms length. I think with this hard training they will either make a man of me or kill me. You ought to see me in my Shrapnel Helmet and Gas Mask, it would make you laugh, especially as the helmet wobbles from side to side, every time I walk. Yes I got my food alright and you can have supper if you like to go for it, and you can bet I always go for supper. I am taking your advice and eating all I can. Yes I did remember Dolly's birthday and I have sent her a little badge of my Regiment which she asked for and which I expect you have received by now. You will have to tell Miss Farmer that I think she will have to wait another two months before she sees me on leave. I will see the officer about the allowance in a day or so, as I have heard today that two or three boys mothers are receiving an allowance, but I don't know how much. Well, I think I will have to close now. As I haven't anything more to say just at present. Hoping you are quite well. From your loving son, Ted. XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX PS. Love to Dolly and Frank After the war Ted Poole's family erected a headstone which bore the inscription, "Out of the stress of the doing, into the peace of the done". He is buried at Naves Communal Extension Cemetery, near Cambrai in France. EJ Poole's letters are held in the documents library at the Imperial War Museum. Extracts are also published in Malcolm Brown's book 1918 Year of Victory.
The above letters were taken from the BBC website Special Report.
a touching tribute Roz - we should never ever forget
ReplyDelete....very touching indeed....I feel so lucky when I read something like this - so sad and Paula is right, we should NEVER EVER FORGET!
ReplyDeleteBeautiful post Roz, so touching...feel so humble after reading it. I would like to say we never forget but we still don't have world peace do we!
ReplyDeleteI have an award for you on my blog. Debbie x
Very moving post.
ReplyDeleteI have some photo's of a poignant war memorial I'd like to post later today (11th) I hope I have time to do them as it is going to be a busy day.